A team of researchers, including Hugh Herr, PhD, conducted a randomized, repeated measures crossover trial to compare two quasi-passive prosthetic ankles (variable stiffness and variable damping) against two energy storage and return (ESR) ankles.
Quasi-passive prosthetic ankle-foot devices can provide functional benefits over passive prostheses without the complexity, weight, and cost of fully powered devices. However, the authors noted, research examining how to best design quasi-passive ankles to optimize patient outcomes was limited. Seven individuals with unilateral transtibial amputations completed eight walking tasks: three level-ground speeds, a figure-eight overground pattern, a 5-degree incline and decline, up stairs, and down stairs. Subject feedback was collected for every ankle on each walking task, and five tasks were biomechanically instrumented using motion capture and force plates.
The results showed that variable damping was, on average, the least preferred across all walking tasks, both from subject feedback and biomechanical metrics. For level-ground walking, the remaining three ankles received similar subject feedback scores, although biomechanical results indicated that the ESR ankles produced higher peak power and center-of-mass push-off work at faster speeds. The variable-stiffness ankle was preferred by subjects over the ESR ankles on decline walking, though no significant difference was seen in the measured biomechanical metrics, according to the study.
The results demonstrated that a quasi-passive variable-stiffness prosthesis can achieve similar level ground walking performance to ESR ankles at slow and moderate speeds, and shows promise in adaptability for walking tasks on sloped terrain, the authors concluded.
The open-access study, “A comparison of passive and quasi-passive prosthetic ankles over varying speeds and terrains,” was published in Scientific Reports.
